Logical?

Ok we'll use your logic and plug in the Clemson QB situation:

You have never said Tajh Boyd is better or that he should replace Kyle Parker. You were not going to be as good IYO if Tajh Boyd had to replace Kyle Parker last year. You are certainly not going to be better this year at QB without Kyle Parker. You think Dabo just liked Parker and that is why he was still on the team and the starter? Its because Boyd is no where near Parker as a QB, just your opinion based on Dabo's actions.

How is your logic now? And don't say it's because Dabo just loved Kyle Parker after that rocky relationship last season. They even showed some affection on national TV last year lol.

Was the reason not that Boyd was just not quite ready last season? That Dabo thought Parker was the best chance to win last season? Can Boyd not be better than Parker this season and beyond even though he rode the bench and watched Parker play nearly the whole season? Why is this situation different than Garcia and Shaw?

Back to Alshon. Let's plug in Clemson again. You lost Spiller and gained Ellington. Even as great as Spiller was you claimed Ellington would be a better RB than Spiller. I agree with you thus far. Why can't the Alson situation play out like that? Where you have a guy in Spiller that is once or twice in a decade but you get a guy that can fill the role as good are better in Ellington. A guy just like Ellington that defenses still have to gameplan around, but maybe not as much? Now, use that same situation and plug in Jacoby Ford and Nuke Hopkins. Just naming simular situations. Situations that got better..

Why are all these position possibilities at Clemson and not Carolina?